Menu Top


Election and Representation (Advanced)

Election And Representation (Class 11)

Election and Representation** are the twin pillars of modern democracy. Elections are the primary mechanism through which citizens choose their representatives, and representation ensures that diverse voices and interests are reflected in the government and its policies.

This involves understanding how electoral systems function, the principles that make elections democratic, and the challenges in ensuring fair representation for all sections of society.


Elections And Democracy

Elections are indispensable for a functioning democracy. They provide the means for:

  • Legitimizing Government: Governments derive their authority from the consent of the governed, expressed through elections.
  • Citizen Participation: Elections allow citizens to participate in the political process and hold their rulers accountable.
  • Peaceful Transfer of Power: They provide a constitutional and peaceful method for changing governments.
  • Policy Responsiveness: Politicians are motivated to be responsive to public opinion and needs to win elections.
  • Representation: Elections ensure that different groups and regions are represented in the legislature.

Without regular, free, and fair elections, a government cannot claim to be democratic.


Election System In India

India employs a mixed electoral system, primarily using the "First Past the Post" (FPTP) system for most elections, but also incorporating elements of Proportional Representation (PR) for specific bodies.

First Past The Post System

In the First Past the Post (FPTP)** system (also known as plurality or winner-take-all):

  • How it works: The country is divided into geographical constituencies, and the candidate who receives the most votes in a constituency wins the election for that seat, regardless of whether they secure an absolute majority (more than 50% of votes).
  • Advantages: It is simple to understand and administer, tends to produce clear winners, and usually leads to stable majority governments. It also fosters a direct link between the elected representative and their constituency.
  • Disadvantages: It can lead to a 'winner's bonus', where a party might win a disproportionately large number of seats compared to its vote share. Smaller parties and independent candidates may find it difficult to win seats. It can also lead to 'wasted votes' (votes cast for losing candidates).
  • Used for: Lok Sabha, State Legislative Assemblies, Panchayats, and Municipalities.

Proportional Representation

In a Proportional Representation (PR)** system:

  • How it works: The seats in the legislature are allocated to parties in proportion to the votes they receive. For example, if a party wins 30% of the votes, it gets approximately 30% of the seats.
  • Advantages: It generally leads to a more accurate reflection of the electorate's preferences in the legislature and encourages representation for smaller parties.
  • Disadvantages: It can lead to coalition governments which may be unstable, and it might weaken the direct link between representatives and specific geographical constituencies.
  • Types of PR:
    • List PR: Voters cast a vote for a party list, and seats are allocated based on the national or regional vote share.
    • Single Transferable Vote (STV): Voters rank candidates in order of preference.

How Does PR Work In Rajya Sabha Elections

Elections to the Rajya Sabha (Council of States), the upper house of the Indian Parliament, use a system of Proportional Representation by means of the Single Transferable Vote (STV)**:

  • Indirect Election: Members of the Rajya Sabha are not directly elected by the people but are elected by the elected members of the State Legislative Assemblies.
  • Vote Transfer: MLAs cast their votes by ranking candidates in order of preference. A candidate needs to secure a certain quota of votes (calculated based on the number of seats and valid votes) to be elected. If a candidate gets more votes than the quota, the surplus votes are transferred to the next preference. If no candidate reaches the quota, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated, and their votes are transferred to their second preference. This process continues until all seats are filled.
  • Representation of States: This system ensures that the Rajya Sabha reflects the strength of different political parties in the state legislatures, indirectly representing the electorate of that state.

Why Did India Adopt The FPTP System?

India adopted the FPTP system for most elections primarily due to:

  • Simplicity: It is relatively easy for voters to understand and for election officials to administer.
  • Stability: It tends to produce single-party majority governments, leading to more stable governance compared to PR systems which often result in coalitions.
  • Direct Accountability: It creates a clear link between a representative and their specific geographical constituency, fostering accountability.
  • Formation of Strong Opposition: It tends to create clear alternatives between a governing party and an opposition party.

While acknowledging its flaws, the FPTP system was chosen for its perceived ability to deliver decisive and stable governance.


Reservation Of Constituencies

Reservation of Constituencies** is a mechanism used in electoral systems to ensure representation for specific groups that have historically faced discrimination or under-representation. In India, this is primarily applied for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).

  • Constitutional Mandate: Articles 330 and 332 of the Constitution provide for the reservation of seats in the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies, respectively, for SCs and STs.
  • How it Works: Certain constituencies are designated as "reserved" for SCs or STs. Only candidates belonging to the specified community can contest elections in these constituencies. The reservation is rotated among different constituencies in periodic delimitation exercises.
  • Purpose: The aim is to ensure that these historically disadvantaged communities have a voice in the legislature and can advocate for their interests.
  • Controversy: While intended to promote representation, the system has also been debated regarding its effectiveness, potential for encouraging caste-based politics, and the need for periodic review.

The reservation policy is a key aspect of India's strategy to achieve social and political equality.


Free And Fair Elections

Free and fair elections are the bedrock of a democratic political system. They ensure that the outcome reflects the genuine will of the people.

Universal Franchise And Right To Contest

These are fundamental pillars of democratic elections:

  • Universal Franchise: The principle that all adult citizens, regardless of their background (caste, religion, gender, economic status), have the right to vote. This is enshrined in the Indian Constitution (Article 326).
  • Right to Contest: While universal franchise ensures the right to vote, the right to contest elections is also crucial. Reasonable restrictions apply (e.g., age limits, nomination requirements, solvency deposits), but these must not be arbitrary or discriminatory. The aim is to allow a wide pool of candidates to participate.

Independent Election Commission

The Independent Election Commission of India (ECI)** is the constitutional authority responsible for conducting elections. Its independence is paramount for ensuring free and fair elections:

  • Autonomy: The ECI operates autonomously from the executive branch of government.
  • Powers: It has comprehensive powers to manage the entire electoral process, from voter registration and delimitation of constituencies to conducting polls, counting votes, and declaring results.
  • Model Code of Conduct: The ECI enforces the Model Code of Conduct to regulate the behaviour of political parties and candidates during the election period, aiming to prevent misuse of government machinery and ensure a level playing field.
  • Supervision and Control: It supervises, directs, and controls the conduct of all elections to Parliament and to the Legislatures of States and elections to the offices of President and Vice-President.

The ECI's independence and proactive role are critical for maintaining public trust in the electoral process.


Electoral Reforms

Electoral reforms** are proposed changes or modifications to the electoral process aimed at improving its fairness, transparency, and efficiency, and addressing challenges that hinder free and fair elections.

Some common areas for electoral reforms include:

  • Campaign Finance: Regulating and limiting election expenditure to reduce the influence of money power and ensure a level playing field. This includes transparency in political funding.
  • Criminalization of Politics: Measures to prevent candidates with criminal records from contesting elections, such as stricter disclosure norms and disqualification criteria.
  • Voter Registration and Turnout: Improving systems for voter registration and increasing voter participation through awareness campaigns and easier access to polling.
  • Role of Media: Regulating media coverage during elections to prevent biased reporting and the spread of misinformation.
  • EVMs and Technology: Ensuring the security and transparency of electronic voting machines and exploring the use of technology for remote voting or better election management.
  • Delimitation of Constituencies: Ensuring that constituencies are drawn on a population basis to maintain fairness in representation, though this is a complex political issue.
  • Strengthening the Election Commission: Enhancing the ECI's powers and independence to effectively address electoral malpractices.

Continuous electoral reforms are essential for strengthening democracy and ensuring that elections truly reflect the will of the people.