Reversible Processes and Carnot Engine

Reversible And Irreversible Processes

Thermodynamic processes can be broadly classified as either reversible or irreversible. This classification is fundamental to the Second Law of Thermodynamics and the concept of efficiency.

Reversible Process

A reversible process is an idealised thermodynamic process that can be reversed by an infinitesimal change in the conditions, such that both the system and its surroundings are restored to their initial states without any net change in the universe.

Key characteristics of a reversible process:

• It must be a quasi-static process, proceeding infinitely slowly through a succession of equilibrium states. This ensures that there are no finite gradients (temperature, pressure) within the system or between the system and the surroundings.
• There are no dissipative effects, such as friction, viscosity, or turbulence.
• Heat transfer occurs without any finite temperature difference (i.e., across an infinitesimal temperature difference).

A truly reversible process is an idealisation that cannot be achieved in reality. However, real processes can sometimes approximate reversible processes if they occur very slowly and dissipative effects are minimized.

Significance: Reversible processes are the most efficient possible processes. A reversible heat engine operating between two temperatures has the maximum possible efficiency. A reversible refrigerator or heat pump has the maximum possible coefficient of performance. Work done in a reversible process is the maximum possible work that can be obtained from a system during expansion between two states, or the minimum work required to compress a system between the same states.

Irreversible Process

An irreversible process is a thermodynamic process that cannot be reversed in such a way that both the system and its surroundings are restored to their initial states. All natural processes are irreversible processes.

Irreversibility arises from factors such as:

• Finite temperature differences: Heat transfer across a finite temperature difference is irreversible (e.g., heat flowing from a hot object to a cold object).
• Dissipative effects: Friction, viscosity, electrical resistance, turbulence, inelastic deformation, etc., convert useful energy into less useful forms (like heat), which cannot be fully recovered.
• Rapid processes: Processes that occur rapidly are typically non-quasi-static, leading to non-equilibrium states within the system and irreversibility.
• Mixing of substances: The spontaneous mixing of gases or liquids is irreversible.
• Free expansion of a gas: Expanding a gas into a vacuum is an irreversible process.

Significance: Irreversible processes are less efficient than reversible processes operating between the same end states. In an irreversible process, the total entropy of the universe always increases. Real engines, refrigerators, and other devices always operate through irreversible processes, resulting in efficiencies lower than the theoretical maximum set by reversible processes.

Entropy and Irreversibility

The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that the total entropy of an isolated system increases in any irreversible process and remains constant in any reversible process. This increase in entropy in irreversible processes quantifies the degree of irreversibility and the loss of available energy for doing work.

Carnot Engine

The Carnot engine is a theoretical, ideal heat engine proposed by Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot in 1824. It is the most efficient possible heat engine operating between two specific temperatures. The Carnot engine operates in a special reversible cycle called the Carnot cycle.

The Carnot cycle consists of four successive reversible thermodynamic processes:

(Image Placeholder: A P-V diagram. Show two isothermal curves at temperatures TH (higher) and TC (lower). Connect points on the higher isotherm to points on the lower isotherm with two adiabatic curves. Label the points A, B, C, D forming a closed loop: A->B Isothermal expansion at TH, B->C Adiabatic expansion (temp drops from TH to TC), C->D Isothermal compression at TC, D->A Adiabatic compression (temp rises from TC to TH).)

Let the working substance be an ideal gas undergoing the following reversible processes:

1. Reversible Isothermal Expansion (A to B): The gas is in thermal contact with the hot reservoir at temperature $T_H$. It absorbs heat $Q_H$ and expands at constant temperature, doing work on the surroundings. ($P$ decreases, $V$ increases).
2. Reversible Adiabatic Expansion (B to C): The gas is insulated. It continues to expand, doing work, and its temperature drops from $T_H$ to $T_C$. (No heat exchange, $Q=0$). ($P$ decreases further, $V$ increases further).
3. Reversible Isothermal Compression (C to D): The gas is in thermal contact with the cold reservoir at temperature $T_C$. Work is done on the gas, and it rejects heat $Q_C$ to the cold reservoir, while its temperature remains constant. ($P$ increases, $V$ decreases).
4. Reversible Adiabatic Compression (D to A): The gas is insulated. Work is done on the gas, and its temperature rises from $T_C$ back to $T_H$. (No heat exchange, $Q=0$). ($P$ increases further, $V$ decreases further, returning to initial state A).

This cycle is reversible, meaning it can be operated in reverse as a reversible refrigerator or heat pump, absorbing heat $Q_C$ at $T_C$, having work $W$ done on it, and rejecting heat $Q_H$ at $T_H$.

The work done by the engine in one cycle is the area enclosed by the cycle on the P-V diagram.

Carnot's Theorem and Efficiency ($ \eta = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} $)

Carnot's analysis of the ideal Carnot cycle led to a fundamental theorem and a formula for the maximum possible efficiency of a heat engine.

Carnot's Theorem

Carnot's Theorem states that:

1. No heat engine operating between two given temperatures can be more efficient than a reversible heat engine operating between the same two temperatures.
2. All reversible heat engines operating between the same two temperatures have the same efficiency, regardless of the working substance.

This theorem establishes that the Carnot engine represents the upper limit of efficiency for any heat engine operating between specified high and low temperatures. It implies that the efficiency of a reversible engine depends only on the temperatures of the hot and cold reservoirs, not on the properties of the working substance.

Efficiency of the Carnot Engine

The efficiency of a heat engine is $\eta = 1 - \frac{Q_C}{Q_H}$. For a reversible engine (like the Carnot engine), the ratio of heat rejected to heat absorbed is directly related to the absolute temperatures of the reservoirs:

$ \frac{Q_C}{Q_H} = \frac{T_C}{T_H} $ (This is derived from the Second Law, or can be shown using the work done in each step of the Carnot cycle for an ideal gas).

For the isothermal expansion from A to B, $Q_H = W_{AB} = nRT_H \ln(V_B/V_A)$. For the isothermal compression from C to D, $Q_C = -W_{CD} = -nRT_C \ln(V_D/V_C) = nRT_C \ln(V_C/V_D)$. The ratio $Q_C/Q_H = \frac{nRT_C \ln(V_C/V_D)}{nRT_H \ln(V_B/V_A)} = \frac{T_C}{T_H} \frac{\ln(V_C/V_D)}{\ln(V_B/V_A)}$. From the adiabatic processes, one can show $V_B/V_A = V_C/V_D$. Thus $\frac{Q_C}{Q_H} = \frac{T_C}{T_H}$.

Substituting this into the efficiency formula $\eta = 1 - \frac{Q_C}{Q_H}$, the efficiency of a reversible (Carnot) engine is:

$ \eta_{Carnot} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} $

where $T_H$ and $T_C$ are the absolute temperatures (in Kelvin) of the hot and cold reservoirs, respectively. These must be the temperatures at which heat transfer occurs.

Implications of the Carnot Efficiency:

• The efficiency is always less than 1, as $T_C$ must be greater than 0 K (absolute zero), and for a heat engine, $T_H > T_C$. This is a direct consequence of the Kelvin-Planck statement.
• To achieve higher efficiency, $T_C$ should be as low as possible, and $T_H$ should be as high as possible.
• An efficiency of 1 (100%) would only be possible if $T_C = 0$ K, which is unattainable according to the Third Law of Thermodynamics.
• The efficiency does not depend on the working substance used in the reversible engine.
• Any real engine operating between the same two temperatures will have an efficiency $\eta_{real} \le \eta_{Carnot}$. The difference ($\eta_{Carnot} - \eta_{real}$) is due to irreversibilities in the real process (friction, finite temperature differences during heat transfer, etc.).

The Carnot cycle and its efficiency formula provide a theoretical benchmark for evaluating the performance of real heat engines and highlight the fundamental limitations imposed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics on energy conversion.

Answer: